Quote:
Originally Posted by nutrinoland
hey...is it true that if the lissajous figure is a horizontal line, then the signal is 180 degrees out of phase....and then that sort of out of phase signal can cause dropouts/cancellations on some music/audio systems or when switched to mono ?
|
Yes, absolutely. Lissajous is great to see what's happening from a stereo viewpoint. If it's a completely horizontal line, then both channels are completely out of phase which may sound amazingly wide on stereo speakers seemingly almost defying the laws of physics, but if played on a mono system you will hear sweet nothing - total silence - the signals will have cancelled each other out when they were summed, seeing as each one is the direct negative (or inverse) of the other. On the contrary, if the lissajous shows a vertical line then it means both L&R channels are playing the same thing, meaning they're both exactly in phase, therefore the signal is effectively mono (or dual mono, if using stereo speakers).
The usual "stereo widening" algorithm takes a copy of the left channel, inverts it, then sums it with the right channel, whilst at the same time takes a copy of the original right channel, inverts it, and adds it to the left channel. In otherwords it's making both channels more out of phase with each other, by erasing any common ground they have in the 'phantom' centre channnel.
You can still use a touch of stereo widening (a small wetness) for the benefit of those who are going to hear it in stereo, but not too much of it otherwise it'd start erasing some of the audio signal if played in mono. It's a compromise.
There are many other ways of being able to increase stereo widening without losing mono compatibility. Chorus, double-tracking, using different instruments playing the same part but panned hard left and hard right respectively, adding reverb, using complementary EQing of both channels of a stereo signal, or even more creative stuff like splitting the signal to M&S format (middle and side) and processing the side-channel before converting the M&S signal back to L&R ... all these things will be summed together when made mono, so although you'll lose the panorama you wont lose any of the audible signal. However the result might sound like there's too much happening when it's all summed to mono as you have so many things going on and now they step on each others toes, overcrowding all of the headroom making it sound busy and muddy, so making a good mix is a compromise between sounding good in stereo whilst still sounding good when merged to mono. Most studios have a mono button on a mixer or similar that you can press to quickly hear what it'll sound like in mono while it's playing back just to keep a check on things.