Quote:
|
Originally Posted by Timo
So, filters aside, why is it that VAs can't match the rawness and character of classic analogue synths, such as the SH101, TB303, JP8, etc.?
I know they can't (I wasn't suggesting they could), but why don't VA coders/programmers rectify this?
|
If VA programmers could.....then I guess they would. True analog components naturally vary, they all interconnect via voltages and because of this...they produce harmonic imperfections which we percieve as desirable (often described as rawness/warmth/presence etc). These imperfections just happen....they are not engineered that way. Now, with digital software....unless you 'program in' these kinda imperfections your going to get very acurate sounds. Hmmm im not sure im making sense. I think the code needed for filters and oscilators etc is very complex....and the time/resources to incur variations is not possible in software yet. Take the TAE of the Arturia synths.....thats a step in the right direction...however, when coders try to program in oscilators that drift, filters that dont track perfectly, 'dirty' virtual vca's and the like...there is still an audiable element of precision. The fact of the matter is....for randomness and rawness...analog components is where its at...and it will always be that way. My analogy of VA is....real time control of sample play back. Ah...i hear you scream...but the fact of the matter is...thats what it sounds like to my ears. Try listening to some real analog poly sounds. Listen to the way those sounds come out of the speakers and enter the listening space. You dont get that VA....and in my opinion will never get that froma digital instrument.
Hence the revival in analog synth manufacturing...
Its an interesting debate. Now, ive had jamming sessions with guitar players etc...and I always find analogs (such as the P5 and JP8..sorry to keep on about this) stand head to head better and in a more satisfying way than VA's do. I think when using VA's you have to be particularly careful with your decision(s) as to what other instruments you want to include. For instance P5 strings and bass go really well with heavy electric guitars......when I did this with the Virus....the Virus sounded like it was unable to breath. This is just my opinion....
DS